I feel like the Giants enjoy teasing their fans with mistake-filled games against inferior opponents followed by almost perfect games against stalwart opponents. Maybe it’s just the randomness of the NFL, but the team’s ability to look great one week and play terribly the next week is mildly infuriating.
Last night, the Giants shocked the league — this time in a good way — with a 36-7 pasting of the Carolina Panthers in Charlotte. The main story line going into the game was that the Giants were missing starting offensive players Ahmad Bradshaw, David Diehl and Hakeem Nicks, but none of that seemed to be a problem. Backup players Andre Brown and Ramses Barden had by far the best games of their respective careers and the offensive line was dominant throughout the night. Furthermore, the Giants handed in their most thorough defensive performance of the season.
The only thing that’s not to like is that New York probably won’t be able to play like this every week. Here’s the five most important takeaways from Thursday night’s romp.
David Wilson “gained” -2 yards rushing
Oops. There was one other thing not to like about New York’s win last night. Highly-touted rookie David Wilson, who looked fantastic in the preseason and training camp, only touched the ball twice and gained a total of one yard. With Wilson’s obvious speed and athleticism, and considering Ahmad Bradshaw was on the shelf with a neck injury, you had to figure he would see at least a share of the carries, but instead Thursday night was the Andre Brown show.
Brown, who upset incumbent D.J. Ware for a roster spot in August, ran 20 times for 113 yards and two touchdowns. He showed great power and patience and gave the Giants a legitimate running back for the first time in what has seemed like ages. I noted in my NFC East report on ProFootballRosters.com that Brown should see at least half the carries if Bradshaw comes back next week. If not, he’ll probably see all of them again. Also worth noting is that with the game out of reach, Tom Coughlin opted to give Da’Rel Scott garbage time carries instead of Wilson.
The Panthers only gained 3.0 yards per carry on the ground
Going into this game, I was afraid that the Giants would be shredded by Carolina’s read option attack, but those fears went unfounded. Last week against New Orleans, the Panthers rushed for 219 yards on 41 carries, but this week they struggled to get any consistency and plodded along for 60 yards on 20 carries. The defensive effort was made even more impressive by the fact that the Giants only had three days to prepare for Carolina, but that appeared to be enough.
New York showed great discipline in attacking the option. At a couple points, Newton seemed unsure if he wanted to hand the ball off or keep it, and this almost led to a pair of fumbles. Justin Tuck in particular was impressive, shutting down a couple of plays with solo tackles right at the line of scrimmage. While DeAngelo Williams broke loose once for a 16-yard gain and ended up with 50 yards rushing on 11 carries, Newton’s biggest gain for the night was a measly three yards long.